Cut selects from an assembly to a 60-second film with match cuts and J and L cuts.
Covers: How to edit a short film: the short answer · Pass 1: the assembly · Pass 2: cut for story and rhythm
Edit a short film in three passes: an assembly, a cut for story and rhythm, then match on action, J and L cuts and frame trims until it runs exactly 60 seconds.
Method. Definitions from MIT's Film Lexicon and our editing lessons (Murch, Smith and Henderson), and Filminute's length rule, checked November 18, 2026. The method and the example EDL are ours. Vinc makes an AI film studio.
How to edit a short film: the short answer
Edit in three passes. First, an assembly: put every select on the timeline in script order, untrimmed, and watch it through once. Second, cut for story and rhythm: trim the start and end of each shot, cut on movement, and drop anything that repeats. Third, polish: use J and L cuts to let sound lead or trail the picture, and trim frame by frame until the film runs exactly 60 seconds. Write down what you did as an edit decision list, so you can rebuild or change the cut later.
Our editing and post terms lesson defines the assembly as the editor's first version, with scenes in script order. For a one-minute film:
Make a new project at your film's frame rate and size. Use the rate your clips came out at.
Put every select on the timeline in shot-list order, with no trimming.
Put the spares on a separate track or in a bin.
Watch it once, all the way through, without stopping. Write notes on paper, not on the timeline.
It'll be too long and slow; the assembly only shows you what you have.
Pass 2: cut for story and rhythm
Ask the questions in this order. Walter Murch's Rule of Six ranks emotion first (51% of his weighting), then story, then rhythm, with the geometry of the screen last; our Rule of Six lesson has the full list from In the Blink of an Eye.
Question
What to do
Does the turn land?
Watch the shots around the turn. If it doesn't land, it's usually a missing reaction; try a spare
Does any shot repeat information?
Cut it, or cut it down
Where does it drag?
Trim the start and end of those shots, not the middle
Where does it confuse?
Add an insert or a reaction, or hold a shot longer
Does each cut fall on a movement or a thought?
Move the cut point there
Trim
Try it
Cut your selects to exactly 60 seconds with one match on action and one J or L cut, and write the edit decision list.
To trim is to shorten a shot by moving its in or out point. Most shots in an assembly start too early and end too late. Start each shot just before something happens and end it just after the audience has understood it.
Pacing
Pacing is the felt speed of a film, set by how long the shots last and how much happens in each. A one-minute film can still breathe: a longer hold on the final image lets the payoff land.
Match on action
Match on action
Match on action is a cut from one shot of an action to another shot of the same action, timed so the movement seems to continue without a gap. MIT's Film Lexicon defines it as "a cut from one shot of an action to a different shot of the action," as quoted in our continuity editing grammar lesson.
How to make one:
Find the movement in shot A (she starts to sit).
Cut out of A partway through the movement.
Start shot B at the same point in the movement, or a frame or two later.
Play it back at full speed. If the movement seems to jump back, start B a few frames later.
The same lesson notes eye-tracking research by Tim Smith and John Henderson that found cuts timed to a sudden onset of motion are the ones viewers most often fail to notice.
J and L cuts
Split edit
A split edit is a cut where the sound and picture change at different times. In a J-cut, the next shot's sound starts before its picture; in an L-cut, the outgoing shot's sound carries on over the next picture. Our editing and post terms lesson defines both.
J-cut: the next shot's sound starts under the current picture, pulling the audience into the cut.
L-cut: the outgoing shot's sound carries on over the next picture, smoothing the cut.
In a short with no dialogue, use them with sound effects and ambience: a sound that belongs to the next shot can start early and make the audience look for it.
Trim to 60 seconds
Cut whole shots that repeat before you shave frames off good ones.
Then trim the heads and tails of every shot by a few frames.
Leave the final shot long enough to read; protect it.
If you're entering a festival with a strict length (Filminute requires "exactly 60 seconds in total running time, including titles and credits", per its call for entries), count your titles and credits inside the 60.
Edit decision list
An edit decision list (EDL) is a list of every event in the cut: which clip, which part of it, and where it sits on the timeline. Editing software can export one, but writing a simple one by hand is a good discipline for a first film.
The assembly. All twelve selects, each generated a second longer than planned, ran 72 seconds. Watching it once gave three notes: the opening wide holds too long before she moves; the jump from reading the note to looking up feels abrupt; the ending is too short to feel the empty room.
The changes.
1A trimmed to start as she enters: 6 s became 5 s.
1C trimmed to 3 s: the envelope reads in less time than planned.
1B to 1C: hard cut on her glance away from the window.
1E to 1F: match on action as she lifts the envelope and starts to sit.
Spare X3 (her hand flattening the note) added before 1G, so the reading feels slower and the look up has something to answer.
1L extended to 7 s so the empty kitchen has time to land.
J-cut: the kettle's rumble starts under 1G, a second before we cut to 1H, where we see the steam.
L-cut: her footsteps from 1K carry on over the empty kitchen in 1L, before the door closes off screen.
The L-cut at the end of The Letter: picture cuts from 1K to the empty kitchen in 1L while Maya's footsteps from 1K carry on underneath. The kettle J-cut into 1H is the same idea in reverse.
Edit decision list. At 24 frames per second; all durations in seconds.
Event
Shot
Duration
Timeline in
Timeline out
Cut and sound
1
1A Wide: Maya enters
5
0:00
0:05
Fade in from black over the first 12 frames
2
1B Medium: kettle, glance at window
6
0:05
0:11
Cut on her glance
3
1C Close-up: the envelope
3
0:11
0:14
Cut
4
1D Medium close-up: she stops
5
0:14
0:19
Cut
5
1E Insert: "From Maya, age 16"
4
0:19
0:23
Cut
6
1F Medium: sits, opens it
5
0:23
0:28
Match on action (sitting)
7
X3 Close-up: hand flattens the note
2
0:28
0:30
Cut
8
1G Insert: "Did you see the sea yet?"
5
0:30
0:35
Kettle rumble starts at 0:34 (J-cut)
9
1H Medium close-up: looks up
5
0:35
0:40
Cut
10
1I Close-up: postcard in sun
4
0:40
0:44
Cut on her eyeline (point of view)
11
1J Close-up: a small laugh
4
0:44
0:48
Cut
12
1K Medium: kettle off, raincoat, out
5
0:48
0:53
Footsteps carry into 1L (L-cut)
13
1L Wide: empty kitchen
7
0:53
1:00
Door closes off screen at 0:56; cut to black at 1:00
Total
60
Thirteen events, twelve planned shots plus one spare. The turn now lands at 0:19–0:23, slightly earlier than planned, which leaves more room for the payoff.
Do it in Vinc
On Cut, score and export, trim on the timeline, mix the score and effects, add captions, and press Render film. Bring your EDL as the plan for the trims.
How we compiled this
Definitions come from our editing lessons, which cite MIT's Film Lexicon, Wikipedia's "Split edit" article, and Walter Murch's In the Blink of an Eye (2nd ed., Silman-James Press, 2001); the Filminute length rule is from its call for entries, read on 18 November 2026. The three-pass method, the trimming order and The Letter's EDL are ours. Vinc makes an AI film studio.
Sources
Walter Murch, In the Blink of an Eye: A Perspective on Film Editing, 2nd ed., Silman-James Press, 2001
Aspect Ratios in Film Explained: 1.33 to 2.39 and 9:16, With the History and Delivery Specs
Aspect ratios in film are width divided by height. See where 1.375, 1.85, 2.39, 16:9, IMAX and 9:16 came from, and the containers cinemas and Netflix expect.